Located on the outskirts of Chicago, Sweet Mischief® LLC specializes in custom sugar cookie favors for events, gatherings, or personal indulgence. Our cookies are made from a delicious, buttery sugar cookie base, available in either classic or chocolate. Each cookie is decorated with royal icing, freshly baked, and contains no preservatives. Note that the cookies include eggs, milk, and wheat*.


Our Story

Our journey began with a simple chocolate chip cookie recipe that consistently satisfied cravings. From there, we expanded our offerings to include various cookie flavors and baked goods. Eventually, we decided to focus on cut-out, decorated sugar cookies, inspired by our cookie Godmother, Anne. Most of our cookies are adorned with royal icing, creating a delightful combination that's perfect for indulging. 

With hundreds of cookie cutters at our disposal, we can craft a cookie favor for almost any occasion. All of our cookies are hand-cut and intricately decorated.

  • Baby

  • Birthday

  • Bridal

  • Cause/Awareness Ribbons

  • Fraternity/Sorority

  • Graduation

  • Holidays including Easter, Christmas, Kwanzaa and Hanukkah

  • Wedding

Interested in something not listed? Just ask using the contact form below.

Our Mantra

Sweet indulgence is permissible, and special occasions should be celebrated without compromise.


*This product is produced in a home kitchen not inspected by a health department that may also process common food allergens. If you have any safety concerns, contact your local health department. The home kitchen is pet and smoke free.

About imageAbout image